English Wikipedia @ Freddythechick:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2010
{{Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2010/Menu}} The eighth elections to the English Wikipedia's Arbitration Committee took place in November and December 2010, and the successful candidates took their seats on 1 January 2011. The election, by practice on Wikimedia projects, is organised by community volunteers independent of the Arbitration Committee.
Election process
{{Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/Series/December 2010 ArbCom election}} The election consisted of three stages.
- The nomination period, during which interested editors were invited to submit a candidate statement. An editor was eligible to stand as a candidate who i) had made 1,000 mainspace edits prior to the start of the nomination period and ii) was in good standing, that is, not subject to active blocks or site-bans.
- The voting period, during which eligible voters may vote on the candidates, using the SecurePoll system. An editor is eligible to vote who (i) has a registered account and has had at least 150 mainspace edits by 1 November 2010; and (ii) is not a blocked user for at least part of the voting period. A tool is available to check the eligibility of user accounts.
- The scrutineering period, during which the votes were be checked (e.g. for duplicate, missing, and ineligible votes) and a tally of results compiled.
Voters were invited to review, question and discuss the candidates throughout the nomination and voting periods.
Personnel
Three groups of editors were involved in the organisation of the elections:
- Election coordinators— self-selected editors organising the on-wiki aspects of the election (listed here).
- Election administrators— Wikimedia Foundation-identified editors who oversaw the election, including the SecurePoll voting system. Happy-melon, MBisanz and Mr.Z-man agreed to serve as election administrators.
- Scrutineers— volunteers drawn from the ranks of stewards with a home wiki other than the English Wikipedia, tasked with verifying the integrity of the vote and tallying the outcome. Dferg, Laaknor, Mardetanha, and Millosh agreed to serve as scrutineers.
The WMF developer Roan Kattouw agreed to run the technical aspect of the election.
Results
Following the voting period, the scrutineers examined the votes, and released a tally of the results. The tally ranks candidates by level of support, defined as the number of votes cast in support of the candidate divided by the total number of votes cast for the candidate ("neutral" votes are not counted). Jimbo Wales ceremonially appointed the candidates to the vacant seats on the Arbitration Committee on the basis of the tally.
Candidate | Support | Neutral[note 1] | Oppose | Net[note 2] | Percentage[note 3] | Result |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Newyorkbrad | 591 | 186 | 73 | 518 | 89.01% | Two-year term |
Casliber | 459 | 267 | 124 | 335 | 78.73% | Two-year term |
SirFozzie | 455 | 270 | 125 | 330 | 78.45% | Two-year term |
Iridescent | 425 | 276 | 149 | 276 | 74.04% | Two-year term |
Elen of the Roads | 381 | 325 | 144 | 237 | 72.57% | Two-year term |
Xeno | 385 | 305 | 160 | 225 | 70.64% | Two-year term |
David Fuchs | 288 | 392 | 170 | 118 | 62.88% | Two-year term |
Chase me ladies, I'm the Cavalry | 320 | 322 | 208 | 112 | 60.61% | Two-year term |
PhilKnight | 285 | 378 | 187 | 98 | 60.38% | Two-year term |
John Vandenberg | 295 | 339 | 216 | 79 | 57.73% | One-year term |
Jclemens | 279 | 358 | 213 | 66 | 56.71% | One-year term |
Shell Kinney | 292 | 335 | 223 | 69 | 56.70% | One-year term |
Sandstein | 296 | 273 | 281 | 15 | 51.30% | |
Stephen Bain | 204 | 402 | 244 | −40 | 45.54% | |
Harej | 195 | 413 | 242 | −47 | 44.62% | |
Georgewilliamherbert | 235 | 319 | 296 | −61 | 44.26% | |
FT2[note 4] | 222 | 323 | 305 | −83 | 42.13% | |
GiacomoReturned | 265 | 200 | 385 | −120 | 40.77% | |
Balloonman[note 4] | 182 | 379 | 289 | −107 | 38.64% | |
Off2riorob | 96 | 281 | 473 | −377 | 16.87% | |
Loosmark[note 5] | 49 | 350 | 451 | −402 | 9.80% |
- ^ All voters were required to register some form of vote for each candidate. The "neutral" column is simply the total votes, minus supports, minus opposes. There is no effective difference between "neutral" and "abstain" as far as this election is concerned.
- ^ Net = Support − Oppose
- ^ Percentage = Support / (Support + Oppose)
- ^ 4.0 4.1 Candidate withdrew from the election after the voting began, and therefore is still listed on the ballot but is ineligible for a position on ArbCom, regardless of the final vote tally.
- ^ Candidate was site banned after the voting began, and therefore is still listed on the ballot but is ineligible for a position on ArbCom, regardless of the final vote tally.
- Results certified by
- I hereby certify this election and its results Mardetanha talk 00:05, 9 December 2010 (UTC)
- --m:dferg 00:10, 09 December 2010 (UTC)
- Laaknor (talk) 00:42, 9 December 2010 (UTC)
- millosh (talk (meta:)) 09:18, 9 December 2010 (UTC)
Vacant seats
The election aimed to raise the number of arbitrators to 18. The terms of nine arbitrators (half of the Committee, by design) were due to expire at the end of 2010—those of Carcharoth, FayssalF, Hersfold, KnightLago, Newyorkbrad, Shell Kinney, SirFozzie, Vassyana, and Wizardman. In addition, Fritzpoll, Rlevse, and Steve Smith, whose terms would not have expired at the end of 2010, stepped down during that year and also needed to be replaced at this election. The number of arbitrators on the Committee (18) and the maximum length of the terms of incoming arbitrators (two years) were established following community discussion in 2009 at this Request for Comment. Thus, 12 arbitrators were elected from the pool of candidates.
DateFormat=mm/dd/yyyy ImageSize= width:1600 height:auto barincrement:21 Period = from:01/01/2004 till:01/31/2016 TimeAxis = orientation:horizontal PlotArea = right:20 left:20 bottom:110 top:5
Colors =
id:bg value:rgb(0.9,0.9,1)
id:elected03 value:rgb(0.88,0.90,0.70) id:elected04 value:rgb(0.70,0.90,0.70) id:elected05 value:rgb(0.70,0.90,0.88) id:elected06 value:rgb(0.70,0.72,0.90) id:elected07 value:rgb(0.86,0.70,0.90) id:elected08 value:rgb(0.90,0.70,0.75)
id:elected09 value:rgb(0.88,0.90,0.70) id:elected10 value:rgb(0.70,0.90,0.70) id:elected11 value:rgb(0.70,0.90,0.88) id:elected12 value:rgb(0.70,0.72,0.90) id:elected13 value:rgb(0.86,0.70,0.90) id:elected14 value:rgb(0.90,0.70,0.75)
id:elected15 value:rgb(0.88,0.90,0.70) id:appointed value:rgb(1,0.8,0.7) id:line value:black id:lightline value:rgb(0.8,0.8,0.8) id:header value:rgb(0.6,0.6,0.9) id:lighttext value:rgb(0.5,0.5,0.5)
BackgroundColors = canvas:bg ScaleMajor = gridcolor:line unit:year increment:1 start:01/01/2004 ScaleMinor = gridcolor:lightline unit:month increment:1 start:01/01/2004
BarData =
Barset:A/E Barset:Key Bar:Blank Bar:T1 Barset:Arbcom1 Bar:T2 Barset:Arbcom2 Bar:T3 Barset:Arbcom3
PlotData=
width:15 textcolor:black
bar:T1 color:header textcolor:white width:20 shift:(-130,-5) fontsize:m from:01/01/2004 till:01/31/2016 text:"Tranche Alpha"
bar:T2 color:header textcolor:white width:20 shift:(-130,-5) fontsize:m from:01/01/2004 till:01/31/2016 text:"Tranche Beta"
bar:T3 color:header textcolor:white width:20 shift:(-130,-5) fontsize:m from:01/01/2004 till:12/31/2009 text:"Tranche Gamma (dissolved, last terms expired 2009-12-31)"
barset:A/E barset:break shift:(5,-5) anchor:from color:appointed from:01/16/2004 till:12/30/2004 text:"Appointed" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected04 from:01/01/2005 till:01/30/2006 text:"Elected" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected05 from:02/01/2006 till:12/30/2006 text:"Elected" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected06 from:01/01/2007 till:12/30/2007 text:"Elected" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected07 from:01/01/2008 till:12/30/2008 text:"Elected" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected08 from:01/01/2009 till:12/30/2009 text:"Elected" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected09 from:01/01/2010 till:12/30/2010 text:"Elected" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:12/30/2011 text:"Elected" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected11 from:01/01/2012 till:12/30/2012 text:"Elected" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected12 from:01/01/2013 till:12/30/2013 text:"Elected" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected13 from:01/01/2014 till:12/30/2014 text:"Elected" width:22 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected14 from:01/01/2015 till:12/30/2015 text:"Elected" width:22 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected15 from:01/01/2016 till:01/30/2016 text:" " width:22 fontsize:m
barset:Key barset:break color:bg from:01/16/2004 till:08/15/2004 text:"Elected" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected03 from:08/15/2004 till:12/30/2004 text:"7/04" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected04 from:01/01/2005 till:01/30/2006 text:"Dec 2004" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected05 from:02/01/2006 till:12/30/2006 text:"Jan 2006" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected06 from:01/01/2007 till:12/30/2007 text:"Dec 2006" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected07 from:01/01/2008 till:12/30/2008 text:"Dec 2007" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected08 from:01/01/2009 till:12/30/2009 text:"Dec 2008" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected09 from:01/01/2010 till:12/30/2010 text:"Dec 2009" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:12/30/2011 text:"Dec 2010" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected11 from:01/01/2012 till:12/30/2012 text:"Dec 2011" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected12 from:01/01/2013 till:12/30/2013 text:"Dec 2012" width:20 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected13 from:01/01/2014 till:12/30/2014 text:"Dec 2013" width:22 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected14 from:01/01/2015 till:12/30/2015 text:"Dec 2014" width:22 fontsize:m barset:break color:elected15 from:01/01/2016 till:01/30/2016 text:" " width:22 fontsize:m
barset:Arbcom1 barset:break shift:(5,-5) anchor:from fontsize:s color:appointed from:01/16/2004 till:12/30/2004 text:"James F." color:appointed from:01/16/2004 till:02/16/2004 text:"UC" color:appointed from:01/16/2004 till:12/30/2004 text:"The Cunctator" at:01/01/2004 barset:break at:01/01/2004 color:elected03 from:08/15/2004 till:12/30/2004 text:"Raul654" at:01/01/2004 color:elected03 from:08/15/2004 till:12/30/2004 text:"Jwr" barset:break color:elected04 from:01/02/2005 till:07/01/2005 text:"Ambi" color:elected04 from:01/02/2005 till:12/31/2007 text:"Raul654" color:elected04 from:01/02/2005 till:11/04/2005 text:"Sannse" color:elected04 from:01/02/2005 till:12/31/2007 text:"Neutrality" barset:break color:appointed from:07/22/2005 till:01/30/2006 text:"James F." at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 barset:break color:elected05 from:02/02/2006 till:12/31/2007 text:"SimonP" at:01/01/2004 color:elected05 from:02/02/2006 till:02/14/2007 text:"Dmcdevit" at:01/01/2004 color:elected05 from:02/02/2006 till:12/31/2007 text:"Fred Bauder" color:appointed from:02/23/2007 till:03/04/2007 text:"Essjay" barset:break at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 color:appointed from:02/23/2007 till:12/31/2007 text:"Mackensen" barset:break color:elected07 from:01/01/2008 till:04/29/2008 text:"Newyorkbrad" barset:break color:elected07 from:08/14/2008 till:12/30/2010 text:"Newyorkbrad" color:elected07 from:01/01/2008 till:01/15/2009 text:"FT2" color:elected07 from:01/01/2008 till:12/30/2010 text:"FayssalF" color:elected07 from:01/01/2008 till:05/23/2009 text:"Sam Blacketer" color:elected07 from:01/01/2008 till:12/30/2008 text:"Deskana" barset:break at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 color:elected08 from:01/01/2009 till:01/20/2010 text:"Vassyana" color:elected08 from:01/01/2009 till:12/30/2010 text:"Carcharoth" color:elected08 from:01/01/2009 till:05/08/2010 text:"Wizardman" barset:break at:01/01/2004 color:elected09 from:01/02/2010 till:12/30/2010 text:"SirFozzie" at:01/01/2004 color:elected09 from:01/02/2010 till:05/13/2010 text:"Hersfold" color:elected09 from:01/02/2010 till:12/30/2010 text:"KnightLago" at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 color:elected09 from:01/02/2010 till:12/30/2010 text:"Shell Kinney" barset:break color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:12/30/2012 text:"Newyorkbrad" color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:12/30/2012 text:"SirFozzie" color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:12/30/2012 text:"Casliber" color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:12/30/2012 text:"Elen of the Roads" color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:12/30/2012 text:"Xeno" color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:12/30/2012 text:"David Fuchs" color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:12/30/2012 text:"PhilKnight" color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:12/30/2011 text:"Chase me ladies" color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:11/11/2011 text:"Iridescent" barset:break at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 color:elected11 from:01/01/2012 till:12/30/2012 text:"Jclemens³" barset:break color:elected12 from:01/01/2013 till:12/30/2014 text:"Newyorkbrad" color:elected12 from:01/01/2013 till:10/03/2013 text:"NuclearWarfare" color:elected12 from:01/01/2013 till:12/30/2014 text:"Worm That Turned" color:elected12 from:01/01/2013 till:12/30/2014 text:"Salvio giuliano" color:elected12 from:01/01/2013 till:12/30/2014 text:"Timotheus Canens" color:elected12 from:01/01/2013 till:12/30/2014 text:"David Fuchs" color:elected12 from:01/01/2013 till:12/30/2014 text:"Carcharoth" color:elected12 from:01/01/2013 till:03/14/2013 text:"Coren" barset:break at:01/01/2012 color:elected13 from:01/01/2014 till:12/30/2014 text:"Beeblebrox" barset:break color:elected14 from:01/01/2015 till:01/30/2016 text:"Guerillero" color:elected14 from:01/01/2015 till:01/30/2016 text:"DGG" color:elected14 from:01/01/2015 till:01/30/2016 text:"DeltaQuad" color:elected14 from:01/01/2015 till:01/30/2016 text:"Salvio giuliano" color:elected14 from:01/01/2015 till:12/30/2015 text:"Euryalus" color:elected14 from:01/01/2015 till:01/30/2016 text:"Doug Weller" color:elected14 from:01/01/2015 till:01/30/2016 text:"Courcelles" color:elected14 from:01/01/2015 till:11/07/2015 text:"Yunshui"
barset:Arbcom2 barset:break shift:(5,-5) anchor:from fontsize:s color:appointed from:01/16/2004 till:01/30/2006 text:"Fred Bauder" color:appointed from:01/16/2004 till:07/01/2005 text:"Delirium" color:appointed from:01/16/2004 till:09/30/2005 text:"Maveric149" color:appointed from:01/16/2004 till:12/30/2004 text:"Camembert" barset:break at:01/01/2004 color:appointed from:07/22/2005 till:01/30/2006 text:"Fennec" color:appointed from:10/12/2005 till:01/30/2006 text:"Mindspillage" color:elected04 from:01/02/2005 till:01/30/2006 text:"David Gerard" barset:break color:elected05 from:02/02/2006 till:12/30/2008 text:"James F." color:elected05 from:02/02/2006 till:12/30/2008 text:"Filiocht" color:elected05 from:02/02/2006 till:12/08/2006 text:" " color:elected05 from:02/02/2006 till:12/30/2008 text:"Charles Matthews" color:elected05 from:02/02/2006 till:12/30/2008 text:"Morven" barset:break at:01/01/2007 color:elected06 from:01/01/2007 till:12/30/2008 text:"YellowMonkey (prev. known as Blnguyen)" color:elected06 from:01/01/2007 till:12/30/2007 text:"FloNight¹" at:01/01/2007 barset:break at:01/01/2007 at:01/01/2007 color:elected07 from:01/01/2008 till:12/30/2008 text:"Stephen Bain²" at:01/01/2007 barset:break color:elected08 from:01/01/2009 till:10/01/2009 text:"Casliber" color:elected08 from:01/01/2009 till:12/31/2011 text:"Risker" color:elected08 from:01/01/2009 till:12/31/2011 text:"Roger Davies" color:elected08 from:01/01/2009 till:12/31/2011 text:"Cool Hand Luke" color:elected08 from:01/01/2009 till:10/31/2010 text:"Rlevse" color:elected08 from:01/01/2009 till:12/02/2009 text:"John Vandenberg" barset:break color:elected09 from:01/02/2010 till:11/25/2010 text:"Steve Smith" at:01/01/2007 at:01/01/2007 at:01/01/2007 at:01/01/2007 color:elected09 from:01/02/2010 till:02/19/2010 text:"Fritzpoll" color:elected09 from:01/02/2010 till:12/30/2011 text:"Kirill Lokshin" color:elected09 from:01/02/2010 till:12/30/2011 text:"Mailer diablo" barset:break color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:12/30/2011 text:"John Vandenberg" at:01/01/2009 at:01/01/2009 at:01/01/2009 color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:12/30/2011 text:"Jclemens³" color:elected10 from:01/01/2011 till:07/04/2011 text:"Shell Kinney" barset: break color:elected11 from:01/01/2012 till:12/30/2013 text:"Courcelles" color:elected11 from:01/01/2012 till:12/30/2013 text:"Risker" color:elected11 from:01/01/2012 till:12/30/2013 text:"Roger Davies" color:elected11 from:01/01/2012 till:03/13/2013 text:"Hersfold" color:elected11 from:01/01/2012 till:12/30/2013 text:"AGK" color:elected11 from:01/01/2012 till:12/30/2013 text:"SilkTork" color:elected11 from:01/01/2012 till:12/30/2013 text:"Kirill Lokshin" barset: break color:elected13 from:01/01/2014 till:12/30/2015 text:"Seraphimblade" color:elected13 from:01/01/2014 till:12/30/2015 text:"GorillaWarfare" color:elected13 from:01/01/2014 till:12/30/2015 text:"Roger Davies" color:elected13 from:01/01/2014 till:12/30/2015 text:"NativeForeigner" color:elected13 from:01/01/2014 till:12/30/2015 text:"AGK" color:elected13 from:01/01/2014 till:12/30/2015 text:"LFaraone" color:elected13 from:01/01/2014 till:07/29/2014 text:"Floquenbeam" color:elected13 from:01/01/2014 till:01/01/2014 text:"28bytes" barset:break at:01/01/2014 at:01/01/2014 at:01/01/2014 at:01/01/2014 at:01/01/2014 at:01/01/2014 color:elected14 from:01/01/2015 till:12/30/2015 text:"Thryduulf" barset:break at:01/01/2016 color:elected15 from:01/01/2016 till:01/30/2016 text:" "
barset:Arbcom3 barset:break shift:(5,-5) anchor:from fontsize:s color:appointed from:01/16/2004 till:12/30/2004 text:"Gutza" color:appointed from:01/16/2004 till:12/30/2004 text:"MyRedDice" color:appointed from:01/16/2004 till:09/30/2005 text:"Nohat" color:appointed from:01/16/2004 till:12/30/2006 text:"The Epopt" barset:break color:elected04 from:01/02/2005 till:07/01/2005 text:"Grunt" color:elected04 from:01/02/2005 till:12/30/2006 text:"Theresa knott" color:appointed from:10/12/2005 till:01/12/2006 text:"KM" barset:break color:appointed from:07/22/2005 till:01/30/2006 text:"Jayjg" barset:break color:elected05 from:02/02/2006 till:12/30/2006 text:"Jayjg" at:01/01/2004 color:elected05 from:02/02/2006 till:12/30/2006 text:"Sam Korn" at:01/01/2004 color:elected05 from:02/02/2006 till:02/19/2006 text:"Mackensen" barset:break color:elected06 from:01/01/2007 till:12/26/2007 text:"Flcelloguy" color:elected06 from:01/01/2007 till:07/11/2009 text:"Kirill Lokshin" color:elected06 from:01/01/2007 till:08/21/2008 text:"Paul August" color:elected06 from:01/01/2007 till:09/23/2008 text:"UninvitedCompany" color:elected06 from:01/01/2007 till:12/25/2008 text:"Jpgordon" barset:break color:elected06 from:01/01/2008 till:12/30/2009 text:"FloNight¹" at:01/01/2004 barset:break at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 color:appointed from:01/01/2009 till:12/30/2009 text:"Stephen Bain²" color:elected08 from:01/01/2009 till:12/31/2009 text:"Coren" barset:break at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 at:01/01/2004 color:elected09 from:01/02/2010 till:12/30/2011 text:"Coren" barset:break barset: break
TextData =
fontsize:S textcolor:lighttext pos:(143,75) text:"¹ FloNight was moved to Tranche Gamma in December 2007, and served until the end of 2009." text:"² Stephen Bain was moved to Tranche Gamma in January 2009, and served until the end of 2009." text:"³ Jclemens was moved to Tranche Alpha in January 2012, and served until the end of 2012."</timeline>
Guides
For candidates
Nominations for candidates opened at 00:01 UTC, Sunday 14 November and closed at 23:59 UTC, Tuesday 23 November. During this time, any editor in good standing who had made at least 1,000 mainspace edits before the opening of the nomination period and was at least 18 years old and of legal age in their jurisdiction was eligible to nominate themselves by following the instructions to create a candidate statement and a questions page on the Candidates' page. Once candidates had created their statements, they could proceed to answer the general and individual questions as they wished (see the Questions page for details and instructions). Candidates could continue to answer questions until the end of the voting period (23:59 UTC, Sunday 5 December).
For voters
Before the nomination period (i.e. before 00:01 UTC, Sunday 14 November), voters were invited to discuss and develop the general questions that will be asked of every candidate.
Once candidates had nominated themselves, voters were invited to review and discuss them. Voters were able to ask one specific question per candidate throughout the election; please see the instructions for individual questions for details.
To facilitate their discussions and judgements, voters were encouraged to familiarise themselves with the candidates. This could be done through reading the candidate statements, the answers to the questions put to each candidate (linked from their candidate statements), and the discussion of each candidate (a centralised collection of which was made available at the Discussion page). In addition, a summary guide to candidates was made available, and augmented by a set of personal guides by individual voters.
Voting ran for 10 days, from 00:01 UTC, Friday 26 November to 23:59 UTC, Sunday 5 December, and was conducted using the SecurePoll extension. Voters used radio buttons to indicate which candidates they would "Support" or "Oppose" (the default option of "Neutral" did not affect the outcome in any way). Because of the risk of server lag, voters were advised to cast their vote at the latest an hour before the close of voting to ensure their vote would be counted.
![]() |
|